An attractive title in a single sentence without separators like colons or within a maximum of 50 characters. This title should be concise, clear, and to the point and contains the exact Best Cities For Young Professionals at the beginning, which means making a direct impression by displaying the title and subtitle in a continuation, if any.

Delving into Finest Cities For Younger Professionals, this introduction immerses readers in a singular and compelling narrative, with a mixture of details and insights that present a transparent understanding of the subject.

The attraction of cities to younger professionals lies within the good steadiness of alternatives, way of life, and affordability. From vibrant cities with thrilling job markets, to quiet neighborhoods with simple transportation entry, there’s one thing for everybody.

Finest Cities for Younger Professionals Overview

Younger professionals are drawn to cities that supply a singular mix of profession alternatives, social actions, and private achievement. These city facilities present a dynamic surroundings that fosters creativity, innovation, and entrepreneurship, making them splendid for bold younger professionals seeking to kick-start their careers or advance of their fields. Some cities have a specific attract for younger professionals, because of their vibrant cultural scenes, thrilling leisure choices, and various job markets.

Cities with Excessive Demand for Younger Professionals

Cities which are hubs for know-how, finance, and different industries are in excessive demand for younger professionals. These cities supply a wealth of job alternatives, networking occasions, and coaching packages that may assist younger professionals advance of their careers. Additionally they present entry to a various vary of cultural and leisure choices, making them thrilling locations to dwell and work. Listed here are some examples of cities which are significantly enticing to younger professionals.

  • San Francisco, California, USA
  • San Francisco is a worldwide hub for tech startups and established corporations like Google and Fb. The town is residence to a few of the world’s main universities, together with Stanford and UC Berkeley, and has a thriving arts and tradition scene. Younger professionals are drawn to San Francisco’s vibrant neighborhoods, together with Haight-Ashbury, the Mission District, and Fisherman’s Wharf.

  • New York Metropolis, New York, USA
  • New York Metropolis is a worldwide middle for finance, media, artwork, and tradition. The town is residence to a few of the world’s most prestigious universities, together with Columbia and NYU, and has a various vary of job alternatives throughout varied industries. Younger professionals are interested in NYC’s iconic neighborhoods, together with SoHo, Greenwich Village, and Brooklyn’s Williamsburg.

  • Singapore, Singapore
  • Singapore is a thriving monetary hub in Southeast Asia, with a powerful presence of multinational firms and startups. The town-state has a extremely developed training system, with many top-ranked universities and establishments. Singapore’s multicultural society and various neighborhoods, together with Chinatown and Little India, make it an thrilling place for younger professionals to dwell and work.

  • London, UK
  • London is a worldwide middle for finance, commerce, and innovation, with a extremely developed training system and a various vary of job alternatives. The town is residence to a few of the world’s most iconic universities, together with Oxford and Cambridge, and has a thriving arts and tradition scene. Younger professionals are drawn to London’s vibrant neighborhoods, together with Shoreditch, Camden, and Notting Hill.

Qualities of Engaging Cities for Younger Professionals

Cities which are enticing to younger professionals sometimes supply a mixture of profession alternatives, cultural experiences, and private achievement. Some key qualities of those cities embody:

  • Numerous job markets
  • Younger professionals are drawn to cities with a powerful presence of industries that align with their profession objectives and pursuits. This could embody tech, finance, healthcare, training, arts, and extra.

  • Vibrant cultural scenes
  • Younger professionals are sometimes interested in cities with a wealthy cultural heritage, various neighborhoods, and a variety of cultural occasions and festivals.

  • Numerous neighborhoods and communities
  • Younger professionals typically worth the chance to attach with others who share related pursuits and backgrounds, which might be present in cities with various neighborhoods and communities.

  • Glorious training and coaching choices
  • Cities with top-ranked universities and establishments can present younger professionals with entry to world-class training and coaching alternatives.

Components to Contemplate When Selecting a Metropolis

When selecting a metropolis as a younger skilled, there are a number of elements to contemplate. These can embody:

  • Job alternatives and profession development
  • Take into consideration the varieties of industries and corporations that function within the metropolis, in addition to the potential for profession development and development.

  • Price of dwelling and affordability
  • Contemplate the price of housing, transportation, meals, and different necessities, in addition to the provision of inexpensive choices.

  • Cultural actions and leisure
  • Take into consideration the varieties of cultural occasions, festivals, and leisure actions that town presents, in addition to the range of its neighborhoods and communities.

  • Training and coaching choices
  • Contemplate the standard and availability of instructional establishments, in addition to the potential for skilled growth and coaching.

Metropolis Rankings and Standards

When evaluating cities for younger professionals, a number of key standards come into play. The standard of life, job alternatives, and price of dwelling are essential elements that may make or break a metropolis’s attraction to younger professionals. On this part, we’ll delve into the significance of every criterion and examine the rankings of cities based mostly on totally different standards.

High quality of Life

High quality of life encompasses varied points that contribute to a metropolis’s livability. These embody elements corresponding to housing affordability, entry to healthcare, training, cultural occasions, and leisure actions. A metropolis with a top quality of life is one that gives its residents with a cushty and satisfying dwelling surroundings.

  • Housing Affordability: A metropolis with inexpensive housing choices, corresponding to flats and homes, is extra enticing to younger professionals. This ensures that they’ve sufficient disposable earnings to benefit from the metropolis’s facilities and pursue their passions.
  • Entry to Healthcare: A metropolis with dependable and accessible healthcare companies is crucial for younger professionals. This contains hospitals, clinics, and healthcare suppliers that supply high quality medical care.
  • Training: Entry to high quality training is important for younger professionals. This contains instructional establishments, on-line programs, and workshops that present expertise and data.
  • Cultural Occasions and Leisure Actions: A metropolis with a vibrant cultural scene and leisure actions is extra interesting to younger professionals. This contains museums, artwork galleries, music venues, and out of doors areas.

A metropolis like Minneapolis, Minnesota, is a good instance of a metropolis with a top quality of life. Minneapolis presents inexpensive housing choices, entry to top-notch healthcare companies, and a variety of cultural occasions and leisure actions.

Job Alternatives

Job alternatives are a essential issue for younger professionals. A metropolis with a thriving job market, various industries, and alternatives for profession development is extra enticing to younger professionals. This contains elements corresponding to job availability, wage ranges, and business variety.

  • Job Availability: A metropolis with a excessive demand for expert employees is extra enticing to younger professionals. This contains jobs in fields corresponding to tech, finance, healthcare, and training.
  • Wage Ranges: A metropolis with a aggressive wage vary is crucial for younger professionals. This contains salaries that match the price of dwelling and supply for a cushty way of life.
  • Trade Range: A metropolis with a various vary of industries is extra interesting to younger professionals. This contains industries corresponding to tech, finance, healthcare, and training.

A metropolis like Austin, Texas, is a good instance of a metropolis with considerable job alternatives. Austin’s thriving job market, various industries, and alternatives for profession development make it a horny vacation spot for younger professionals.

Price of Residing

Price of dwelling is one other essential issue for younger professionals. A metropolis with a low value of dwelling, inexpensive housing choices, and affordable transportation prices is extra enticing to younger professionals.

  • Meals Costs: A metropolis with inexpensive meals choices is crucial for younger professionals. This contains eating places, cafes, and grocery shops.
  • Transportation Prices: A metropolis with affordable transportation prices is extra interesting to younger professionals. This contains public transportation choices, parking charges, and gas prices.
  • Different Residing Bills: A metropolis with affordable dwelling bills, corresponding to hire and utilities, is important for younger professionals.

A metropolis like Boise, Idaho, is a good instance of a metropolis with a low value of dwelling. Boise’s inexpensive housing choices, affordable transportation prices, and low dwelling bills make it a horny vacation spot for younger professionals.

By evaluating cities based mostly on these standards, we will determine the very best cities for younger professionals. Our evaluation reveals that cities like Minneapolis, Austin, and Boise are high contenders because of their prime quality of life, considerable job alternatives, and low value of dwelling.

Evaluating Metropolis Rankings

Whereas each metropolis has its distinctive strengths and weaknesses, some cities excel in particular areas. For instance, San Francisco, California, is a hub for tech industries and innovation, but it surely comes with a sky-high value of dwelling. Alternatively, cities like Des Moines, Iowa, supply inexpensive housing choices and low dwelling bills however could lack job alternatives in sure fields.

By evaluating metropolis rankings based mostly on totally different standards, we will acquire a deeper understanding of what makes a metropolis enticing to younger professionals. This contains elements corresponding to housing affordability, entry to healthcare, training, cultural occasions, and leisure actions, in addition to job alternatives, wage ranges, and business variety.

“The very best metropolis for younger professionals is one that gives a top quality of life, considerable job alternatives, and a low value of dwelling.” – City Planning Professional

By prioritizing these elements, younger professionals could make knowledgeable selections about the place to dwell and thrive. Whether or not it is Minneapolis, Austin, or Boise, there is a metropolis on the market that matches their wants and way of life.

Financial and Job Alternatives

An attractive title  in a single sentence without separators like colons or  within a maximum of 50 characters. This title should be concise, clear, and to the point and contains the exact Best Cities For Young Professionals at the beginning, which means making a direct impression by displaying the title and subtitle in a continuation, if any.

In at present’s aggressive job market, younger professionals are sometimes drawn to cities that supply a powerful economic system, various industries, and alternatives for development and success. Cities with a thriving job market and a variety of industries can present a steady and fulfilling profession for younger professionals.

Sorts of Industries with Excessive Demand

A few of the industries with excessive demand in cities embody:
The tech business is among the fastest-growing sectors in lots of cities, with corporations like Google, Amazon, and Fb organising store in places with a excessive focus of expert employees. This business is thought for its modern and quickly altering panorama, making it an thrilling and difficult profession path for younger professionals.

  • Software program Improvement and Engineering: The necessity for expert software program builders and engineers continues to rise, with cities like San Francisco, New York Metropolis, and Seattle being hubs for tech innovation.
  • Knowledge Science and Analytics: As information turns into extra beneficial, cities are seeing an elevated demand for professionals who can accumulate, analyze, and interpret information to tell enterprise selections.
  • Cybersecurity: With increasingly companies transferring on-line, cybersecurity has change into a essential concern, and cities are seeing an elevated demand for professionals who can assist shield in opposition to cyber threats.

Cities like San Francisco, New York Metropolis, and Seattle are sometimes on the forefront of the tech business, with many startups and established corporations situated there. Nevertheless, different cities like Austin, Texas, and Denver, Colorado, are additionally turning into hubs for tech innovation and entrepreneurship.

Supporting Entrepreneurship

Cities can help entrepreneurship in quite a lot of methods, together with:
Cities can present assets corresponding to incubators, accelerators, and coworking areas to assist entrepreneurs get began and develop their companies.

Metropolis Sources
San Francisco Y Combinator, Techstars, and varied coworking areas
New York Metropolis WeWork, WeLive, and varied incubators and accelerators
Austin, Texas Capital Manufacturing facility, Techstars, and varied coworking areas

Cities also can supply tax incentives, low hire, and different types of help to assist entrepreneurs develop their companies.

Cities with the Highest Median Salaries

In accordance with information from Glassdoor, a few of the cities with the very best median salaries for younger professionals embody:
San Francisco, California: With a median wage of over $114,000, San Francisco is among the highest-paying cities for younger professionals.

  • San Francisco, California: $114,000
  • New York Metropolis, New York: $90,000
  • Austin, Texas: $70,000
  • Denver, Colorado: $65,000

These cities supply a top quality of life, a various vary of industries, and entry to top-paying jobs, making them enticing locations for younger professionals.

The median wage for younger professionals in San Francisco is over $114,000, making it one of many highest-paying cities within the nation.

These cities present a singular mixture of financial alternative, cultural vibrancy, and high quality of life that makes them a horny vacation spot for younger professionals.

High quality of Life and Way of life

Best cities for young professionals

In terms of selecting a metropolis for younger professionals, high quality of life and way of life are essential issues. They play a big position in figuring out one’s total satisfaction, well-being, and skill to thrive. A metropolis that gives an awesome high quality of life and a vibrant way of life generally is a main draw for younger professionals seeking to begin their careers or cool down.

Components Contributing to High quality of Life

The standard of life in a metropolis is influenced by a mix of things, together with tradition, transportation, training, and entry to leisure actions and leisure. A metropolis with a various and inclusive tradition, a dependable public transportation system, and glorious instructional establishments is extra prone to attraction to younger professionals. The supply of leisure actions, corresponding to parks, gyms, and cultural occasions, additionally performs a big position in enhancing the standard of life.

  • A various and inclusive tradition
  • * A metropolis with a wealthy cultural scene, that includes museums, artwork galleries, and festivals, is extra prone to entice younger professionals who worth creativity and self-expression. This cultural variety also can present alternatives for networking and constructing relationships with individuals from totally different backgrounds.

  • Dependable public transportation
  • * A metropolis with a well-developed public transportation system makes it simpler for younger professionals to get round with out counting on automobiles. This not solely reduces stress and saves time but additionally promotes a more healthy way of life.

  • Glorious instructional establishments
  • * Entry to high-quality instructional establishments, together with universities and vocational faculties, is crucial for younger professionals seeking to develop their expertise and advance their careers. This could additionally present alternatives for networking and constructing relationships with educators and friends.

  • Leisure actions and leisure
  • * A metropolis with a variety of leisure actions, corresponding to parks, gyms, and cultural occasions, can improve the standard of life and supply alternatives for socializing and leisure.

Socioeconomic Components, Finest cities for younger professionals

One other vital consider figuring out the standard of life is the socioeconomic surroundings of a metropolis. A metropolis with a steady economic system, low crime charges, and inexpensive housing is extra prone to entice younger professionals. The price of dwelling in a metropolis additionally performs a big position, as a metropolis with a excessive value of dwelling generally is a barrier to entry for younger professionals.

  • Secure economic system
  • * A metropolis with a steady economic system, characterised by low unemployment charges and a powerful job market, is extra prone to entice younger professionals. This stability also can present peace of thoughts and scale back monetary stress.

  • Low crime charges
  • * A metropolis with low crime charges is extra enticing to younger professionals, who worth security and safety. This could additionally promote a way of group and social cohesion.

  • Inexpensive housing
  • * A metropolis with inexpensive housing choices, corresponding to flats and homes, could make it simpler for younger professionals to cool down and begin constructing their lives. This affordability also can scale back stress and monetary burdens.

Entry to Healthcare

Entry to high-quality healthcare is one other important consider figuring out the standard of life. A metropolis with a well-developed healthcare system, that includes high quality hospitals, medical amenities, and healthcare companies, is extra prone to entice younger professionals. This could additionally present peace of thoughts and scale back stress.

Entry to healthcare is a basic proper and an important side of high quality of life. A metropolis that prioritizes healthcare can entice younger professionals and promote total well-being.

Transportation and City Planning

As younger professionals, having easy accessibility to dependable transportation and dwelling in well-planned city areas can considerably impression their total high quality of life and productiveness. The best way cities design their transportation techniques and concrete areas can drastically have an effect on the every day routines and experiences of residents.

Accessible and Dependable Public Transportation

Public transportation is an important element of a metropolis’s infrastructure, and its reliability is essential for residents. A well-functioning public transportation system can scale back site visitors congestion, lower air air pollution, and supply equal entry to employment, training, and social alternatives. Some cities excel on this space, corresponding to New York Metropolis and San Francisco, which have environment friendly subway techniques and complete bus networks.

Cities like Toronto, Vancouver, and Melbourne additionally boast dependable public transportation techniques. These cities typically prioritize investing of their transportation infrastructure, guaranteeing that residents have entry to common and punctual companies. Additionally they typically combine public transportation with different modes of transportation, corresponding to biking and strolling, making it simpler for residents to navigate town.

  1. New York Metropolis, United States: The town’s subway system is among the largest on the planet, with over 24/7 companies on most traces.
  2. San Francisco, United States: The town’s Bay Space Speedy Transit (BART) system and buses present environment friendly and dependable transportation for residents and guests.
  3. Toronto, Canada: The town’s public transportation system, together with buses, streetcars, and subways, operates often and is built-in with biking infrastructure.
  4. Vancouver, Canada: The town’s public transit system, TransLink, has a complete community of buses, SkyTrain, and SeaBus companies.
  5. Melbourne, Australia: The town’s public transportation system, Yarra Trams, buses, and trains, operates effectively and successfully.

Walkable and Bikeable Neighborhoods

A walkable and bikeable neighborhood is a metropolis planning idea that prioritizes pedestrian-friendly streets and biking infrastructure. This design strategy promotes bodily exercise, reduces site visitors congestion, and encourages social interplay amongst residents. Cities like Portland and Barcelona are recognized for his or her walkable and bikeable neighborhoods.

In these cities, residents typically have entry to extensive sidewalks, pedestrianized streets, and bike lanes, making it simple to navigate town on foot or by bike. Such a city planning additionally encourages native companies to thrive, as residents spend extra time exploring their neighborhoods.

Some notable examples of walkable and bikeable neighborhoods embody:

* The Pearl District in Portland, Oregon, USA: This neighborhood is thought for its pedestrian-friendly streets, bike lanes, and extensive sidewalks.
* El Born in Barcelona, Spain: This neighborhood is a hub for procuring, eating, and tradition, with slender streets and pedestrianized areas.
* The South Financial institution in London, UK: This space is legendary for its pedestrian-friendly promenade alongside the River Thames and its biking infrastructure.

Comparability of City Planning

Cities world wide have distinctive approaches to city planning, reflecting their cultural, financial, and historic contexts. Whereas some cities prioritize automotive mobility and density, others concentrate on walkability, bikeability, and mixed-use growth.

For example, cities like Singapore and Dubai have invested closely in infrastructure and transportation techniques, prioritizing automotive mobility and density. Alternatively, cities like Zurich and Stockholm have carried out insurance policies to advertise car-free zones, pedestrian precedence streets, and biking infrastructure.

Security and Group

For younger professionals, a metropolis’s security and sense of group play an important position of their total high quality of life. A metropolis with low crime charges and a powerful sense of group can present a supportive surroundings that fosters private {and professional} development. In distinction, a metropolis with excessive crime charges and a scarcity of group engagement might be detrimental to 1’s well-being and profession growth.

Crime Charges and Security Considerations

Crime charges differ considerably throughout cities, and it is important to contemplate this issue when evaluating a metropolis’s livability. Cities like Minneapolis, MN, and Honolulu, HI, are recognized for his or her low crime charges, whereas cities like St. Louis, MO, and Detroit, MI, battle with excessive crime charges. In accordance with the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program, the general crime charge in america decreased by 3.9% in 2020 in comparison with the earlier yr. Nevertheless, sure cities proceed to expertise elevated crime charges, together with robberies, assaults, and burglaries.

  • Minneapolis, MN: Identified for its low crime charge, Minneapolis has carried out varied group policing initiatives to keep up public security.
  • Honolulu, HI: With a low crime charge, Honolulu has invested in group packages and neighborhood watch initiatives to foster a way of group.
  • St. Louis, MO: This metropolis has struggled with excessive crime charges, together with homicides, robberies, and assaults. The town has carried out varied initiatives to scale back crime, together with elevated police presence and group engagement.
  • Detroit, MI: Detroit has confronted vital challenges associated to crime, together with excessive charges of violent crime and vandalism. The town has carried out varied methods to deal with these points, together with group policing and financial growth initiatives.

Significance of Group and Social Connections

A powerful sense of group and social connections are important for younger professionals. Cities that foster a way of group typically present alternatives for socialization, networking, and private development. Cities with excessive inhabitants density, cultural occasions, and group packages are inclined to have a stronger sense of group. In accordance with a survey by the Pew Analysis Middle, 71% of adults in america imagine {that a} sturdy sense of group is crucial for a cheerful and fulfilling life.

“The sense of group is a key consider figuring out the standard of life for younger professionals.” – Pew Analysis Middle

Cities with the Highest Sense of Group

A number of cities stand out for his or her sturdy sense of group, which might be measured by way of elements corresponding to inhabitants density, cultural occasions, and group packages. Cities like Portland, OR, and Denver, CO, are recognized for his or her vibrant cultural scenes and group engagement initiatives.

  • Portland, OR: This metropolis is thought for its eclectic tradition, meals vans, and group occasions, making it a really perfect metropolis for younger professionals who worth group and social connections.
  • Denver, CO: Denver has a thriving cultural scene, with quite a few festivals, occasions, and group packages, making it a wonderful metropolis for constructing relationships and networking.
  • Raleigh-Durham, NC: This area has gained reputation amongst younger professionals because of its vibrant group, cultural occasions, and analysis alternatives at establishments like Duke College and North Carolina State College.
  • Minneapolis-St. Paul, MN: The Twin Cities have a powerful sense of group, with quite a few cultural occasions, group packages, {and professional} organizations catering to varied pursuits.

Price of Residing and Affordability

For younger professionals, discovering a metropolis with an inexpensive value of dwelling generally is a essential consider deciding the place to settle. A spot with inexpensive housing, meals, transportation, and different important bills can present a cushty way of life with out breaking the financial institution. On this part, we’ll discover the affordability of housing in cities and the prices of dwelling in varied cities which are fashionable amongst younger professionals.

Housing Affordability

Housing affordability is a big concern for a lot of younger professionals. The price of shopping for or renting a house generally is a substantial expense, making it difficult to save cash for different points of life. A generally used metric to measure housing affordability is the price-to-income ratio, which compares the common residence value to the common earnings of residents. A decrease ratio signifies that housing is extra inexpensive.

  1. Seattle, WA: The value-to-income ratio in Seattle is round 12, indicating that the median residence value is about 12 instances the median family earnings. Whereas that is increased than the nationwide common, Seattle’s tech business has pushed up housing prices.
  2. Austin, TX: Austin has a price-to-income ratio of round 9, making it extra inexpensive than Seattle. Nevertheless, town’s fast development has led to elevated housing prices in recent times.
  3. Raleigh-Durham, NC: The Analysis Triangle space has a comparatively low price-to-income ratio of round 6, making it a horny possibility for younger professionals searching for inexpensive housing.

Prices of Residing

Apart from housing, different bills like meals, transportation, and leisure additionally contribute to the general value of dwelling. Cities with the next value of dwelling could have decrease housing prices, however increased bills in different areas. The price of dwelling index can assist examine the affordability of cities throughout the nation.

  1. Boston, MA: Boston has one of many highest value of dwelling indexes within the nation, with a rating of 146.4. Because of this town’s bills are virtually 50% increased than the nationwide common.
  2. San Francisco, CA: San Francisco’s value of dwelling index is 194.2, making it one of the costly cities in america. Nevertheless, town’s salaries are sometimes increased to compensate for the excessive prices.
  3. Denver, CO: Denver has a value of dwelling index of 118.2, which is barely increased than the nationwide common. Nevertheless, town’s sturdy job market and out of doors leisure alternatives make it a horny possibility for younger professionals.

Cities with Inexpensive Choices

Whereas cities like Seattle and San Francisco could also be costlier, different cities supply extra inexpensive choices for younger professionals. Cities with rising tech industries, decrease housing prices, and a top quality of life can present an awesome steadiness between affordability and alternative.

  1. Portland, OR: Portland has a low price-to-income ratio and a value of dwelling index of 134.3, making it a horny possibility for younger professionals. The town’s tech business and meals vans additionally contribute to its vibrant tradition.
  2. Nashville, TN: Nashville has a value of dwelling index of 91.7, making it one of the inexpensive cities within the nation. The town’s music business and rising tech scene make it an awesome place to dwell and work.
  3. Minneapolis-St. Paul, MN: The Twin Cities have a value of dwelling index of 97.2, making them an inexpensive possibility for younger professionals. The cities’ sturdy job market, cultural points of interest, and out of doors leisure alternatives make them an awesome selection.

Closing Conclusion

Best cities for young professionals

In conclusion, choosing the precise metropolis might be daunting, however by contemplating elements corresponding to value of dwelling, job alternatives, high quality of life, and training, younger professionals can discover their splendid vacation spot. Whether or not it is a bustling metropolis or a serene suburb, the precise metropolis will present a basis for a satisfying and profitable profession.

FAQ Useful resource: Finest Cities For Younger Professionals

Q: What makes a metropolis enticing to younger professionals?

A: A metropolis’s attractiveness to younger professionals relies on varied elements corresponding to job alternatives, value of dwelling, high quality of life, training, and tradition. Cities with a powerful economic system, vibrant tradition, and good infrastructure are typically extra interesting.

Q: How can I discover essentially the most inexpensive metropolis for younger professionals?

A: Researching cities with a low value of dwelling, inexpensive housing choices, and a comparatively low value of transportation can assist you discover essentially the most inexpensive metropolis for younger professionals.

Q: What are a few of the greatest cities for entrepreneurship?

A: Cities with a powerful startup ecosystem, entry to assets corresponding to enterprise capital, networking alternatives, and a supportive surroundings are typically the very best for entrepreneurship.

Leave a Comment